It’s been proposed that phonics should be included in the Entry Levels of the English Functional Skills qualification. That’s great news unless the people delivering the phonics think it’s boring and babyish, in which case it’s doomed. Instead, here’s a vision for age-appropriate phonics delivered with enthusiasm and understanding. A vision of lessons which are fresh, challenging, satisfying and safe for people who’ve had negative experiences of school.
I’ve been using Linguistic Phonics with older struggling readers for many years. Along the way I’ve made lots of mistakes and seen lots of mistakes made by others. Here are a few that can be avoided by approaching phonics with an open mind, a love of the language and high expectation that previously discouraged learners can discover a new way to get over lifelong barriers to reading and writing.
Error 1: Approaching phonics as a subject to be taught.
There is lots to know about how the sounds of English are represented in writing. However, adult learners at the beginning levels don’t need more knowledge about English. They need a tool that will quickly help them to read and spell. My worst-case scenario would have students being shown a letter and told what sound it makes. This feels like infant school and is unnecessary for most learners.
Instead: Rather than learning about phonics, students need to be using phonics in the context of whole meaningful words from the first minute and lessons should be about much more than remembering which letter represents which sound. At every step, learners should be gaining more understanding about how the language works and picking up the vocabulary to discuss reading and spelling. You want everyone in the room to be saying, “Oh! Is this how it works? I can do this.” Think of the early phases of phonics for adults as a framework. They’ll learn to read and spell a huge volume of straightforward words, but they’ll also develop the language and the confidence to ask the right questions so they can cope with the complexity of English and increasingly difficult text completely free of anxiety. The knowledge will come but not as a result of top-down lessons which might remind them of the trauma of school.
The bonus of using this approach is that classmates can support one another in a consistent manner. They might not have all the answers but they’ll have shared language for helping each other get to the right word or spelling.
Error 2: Starting with reading. This quickly becomes an exercise in analysing the written word. “Here’s the word fan – what are the sounds you see in fan?”
Instead: Start with speaking and listening – things your students can already do – and approach phonics first through spelling which is a much more grown-up activity. Of course, many adult learners panic at the thought of spelling, so initially we call it building and support students with visual clues like simple uncluttered charts or puzzle pieces so success is guaranteed and they can focus on seeing how the sounds match the symbols. You can easily differentiate as some students will lean heavily on the visual clues and others will go directly to spelling without realising that’s what they’re doing.
Error 3: Poorly structured delivery. This leads to spending far too much time on basic word constructions like cat, sit, top, etc and boring your learners.
Instead: Think out your delivery very carefully with incremental steps that support the learners but lead to rapid improvement. The more supported the delivery is in the early phases, the more confident learners become and the quicker you can remove the supports.
In the first lesson they should realise that, if they can read sap, tip, bet etc, then there are hundreds of words that are now within their reading vocabularies. You don’t have to go through every one of them to prove it. The next lesson will continue to practice those types of words but with the addition of words like runt, lamp, tent etc. By adding in sh/ch/the and split vowels (like, cake, mute, etc) each learner should have a huge volume of words they can read and spell in a very few lessons.
Error 4: Assuming that “babyish” is inevitable and compensating by adding in complex code too soon.
Instead: Don’t jump ahead to the complex code too quickly on the assumption that the basic code is too babyish. In That Reading Thing, we keep things age-appropriate by using mature vocabulary, working with multisyllabic words in the first lesson and then by adding common endings to basic code words. By scaffolding the lessons we get learners reading and spelling words like description, recognition and condition within a few lessons because they feel safe and supported and the only difficult thing about those words is the tion ending. Because of previous lessons, they can extend condition to conditioned, conditioning, conditioner etc. This is extraordinarily satisfying for adult learners.
Getting them to that stage quickly requires working with multisyllabic words from the first lesson. Many learners have decided they can read little words but not big ones and it’s essential to build confidence in this area before attacking the more complex code. When a discouraged adult spells fantastic in the first lesson it’s a milestone event!
Error 5: Alan Wells, the former head of the old Basic Skills Agency said the following:
“For adults, who have far more problems than young children, I doubt whether phonics are going to work. They have a wide range of problems, from spelling to poor comprehension.”
This idea is endemic in adult literacy. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had a conversation which started with the idea that phonics is disconnected from literacy as a whole. This assumption is simply wrong.
Spelling: At the early levels, spelling and reading happen together. At the advanced levels, spelling is more complex but a phonics framework allows for best use of limited memory – far better than remembering strings of letter names or visualising whole words.
Comprehension: When working with adults, never stop talking about meaning. At word level, you make sure every word has meaning and is understood in the context of whole sentences. Speaking and listening are essential in good phonics delivery.
When an error is made in decoding, so that the sentence changes meaning or has no meaning at all, you ask, “Does that make sense?” What about when the decoding is wrong but the sentence might still make sense? Older learners have often given up on reading for meaning so it’s important to knock “approximate reading” on the head – even when the words may be similar. If an adult reads house when the word is home, it might very well still make sense, but it lacks nuance and it’s disrespectful to our learners to exclude them from that age-appropriate element of reading.
Error 6: Following on from the above is the idea that correcting adults is bad for their self-esteem.
Instead: Saying something’s right when it’s wrong leaves learners open to making the same mistake around people who aren’t going to be so kind. Nothing improves the self-esteem of an adult with low literacy like learning to read and spell. Nothing. Use sting-free, shame-free error correction. Be positive and encouraging. But don’t let adult learners think they’re right when any other literate person would know they’re wrong. Patronising adults is bad for their self-esteem.
There are a book-load of things that can be said about using phonics in adult literacy but that’s enough to be thinking about for now. I look forward to working with the colleges already using TRT in one-to-one support to see how it might developed into a flexible tool for the classroom.
I know people were hoping I’d critique on the phonics elements of Functional Skills Subject Content English. I’ll get to that another day. The above rather wrote itself on the way to commenting on the document.